Organisations recruit experienced leaders to transform departments. But what happens when the mandate they've advertised exceeds the authority they're willing to grant?
There's a particular kind of job advertisement that appears regularly in the Brussels bubble.
An organisation is looking for a senior leader. Someone with 10, 15, perhaps 20 years of experience. Someone who can set strategic direction, build and lead a high-performing team, strengthen organisational capacity, oversee budgets and resources, and contribute to executive-level decision-making.
The language is ambitious.
We're looking for a strategic leader with a proven track record of delivering results. Someone who can drive continuous improvement, foster a high-performing culture and provide leadership through periods of growth and change.
You apply. You go through several interviews. You discuss your vision, explain what needs improving and how you would build the function.
They hire you.
And then you start doing what you were hired to do.
You assess existing structures. You question processes. You clarify responsibilities. You introduce accountability. You make decisions about priorities, resources and people.
Some colleagues welcome the changes. Others are less enthusiastic.
And gradually, the strategic thinking that impressed the interview panel becomes challenging the way we do things here. Your willingness to make difficult decisions becomes a concern about your leadership style. Your efforts to establish clearer accountability become creating unnecessary tension.
And somewhere around the 18-month mark, the organisation decides that perhaps you're not the right fit after all.
The mandate advertised versus the authority granted
An organisation can give someone an impressive title, a seat on the executive team and responsibility for transforming a department. But none of those things necessarily means they have the authority to make the changes required.
You may be accountable for the department's performance, but unable to make decisions about its structure.
You may be expected to build a high-performing team, but find that decisions about people are subject to informal agreements made long before you arrived.
You may be asked to introduce new processes, only to discover that senior colleagues are exempt from following them.
And you may sit on the executive team while the decisions that matter continue to be made elsewhere.
The result is a peculiar kind of leadership role: responsibility for outcomes without corresponding authority over the conditions that produce them.
Because changing a department often means questioning how the wider organisation operates. Its decision-making habits, informal hierarchies and long-standing relationships.
And that requires something much more difficult than hiring an experienced executive.
It requires the existing leadership to change too.
The real test: How much change can the organisation tolerate?
Organisational commitment to change is relatively easy to express during recruitment.
It's considerably harder to sustain when the consequences become personal.
When a restructuring affects a long-serving colleague. When a new accountability framework exposes weaknesses in existing leadership. When a department head questions decisions that have traditionally gone unchallenged.
Sometimes, the executive discovers that the organisation wanted better performance without changing how decisions are made. Greater accountability without difficult conversations. A stronger department without redistributing authority.
And when the executive pushes beyond those limits, the discussion can shift from the changes themselves to the person leading them.
Are they collaborative enough? Do they understand the culture? Are they the right fit?
Of course, senior executives can get things wrong. They can move too quickly, underestimate organisational history or fail to bring people with them.
But there's an important difference between a leader who manages change poorly and an organisation that withdraws its support when change becomes uncomfortable.
The 18-month reckoning
Eighteen months can be enough time to understand an organisation, identify structural weaknesses and begin implementing change.
It's also when the consequences of those decisions become visible. And sometimes, the easiest response is to replace the person leading the change. The departure is explained in familiar corporate language.
A difference in leadership approach. A question of cultural fit. A need for a different profile for the next phase.
Sometimes those explanations are justified. But sometimes they leave a more uncomfortable question unanswered:
Did the executive fail to deliver the change, or did the organisation struggle to accommodate it?
What senior leaders should learn from this
For experienced professionals considering their next executive role, perhaps the most important part of recruitment isn't demonstrating that you can do the job.
It's establishing whether the organisation is prepared to let you.
When a hiring committee says a department needs transformation, ask what has prevented that transformation until now.
When they promise autonomy, ask which decisions you will actually control and who can overrule them.
When they want someone who can challenge established practices, ask when senior leadership last accepted a challenge and changed its own approach.
And when they describe the organisation as ready for change, ask what its leaders are personally prepared to do differently.
These questions may reveal more than another presentation of your 100-day plan.
They may also make the interview slightly uncomfortable.
Which, for a senior leadership appointment, isn't necessarily a bad thing.
And for organisations doing the hiring, perhaps the same questions deserve asking internally.
What exactly are we asking this person to change? What authority are we prepared to give them? And what are we, as existing leaders, prepared to change ourselves?
Because if, 18 months later, the conclusion is that the person hired to bring strategic leadership, strengthen a department and improve its performance has become too challenging, perhaps the performance review needs to go both ways.
The next time an organisation recruits an experienced executive, it might be worth asking whether it's prepared to let that person exercise the very judgement and leadership it hired them for.